TLDR Shares of Fair Isaac tumbled 7% in after-hours trading Thursday following a Bloomberg report about potential FHFA regulatory changes. The Federal Housing Finance Agency is considering ma
Fair Isaac (FICO) shares tumbled 7% in extended trading Thursday. TransUnion (TRU) shares fell 6% during the same period.
The sell-off came after Bloomberg published a report about a potential regulatory shift. The Federal Housing Finance Agency is weighing a requirement that would force lenders to obtain credit information from just two bureaus rather than the current three.
This proposed modification would affect mortgages guaranteed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Current industry practice involves a “tri-merge” credit report that compiles information from all three dominant credit reporting agencies.
FHFA Director Bill Pulte may unveil the policy change as early as October 12. His appearance at a Chicago mortgage industry conference is scheduled for that date.
The FHFA declined to provide comment when contacted about the Bloomberg story. No official schedule has been released by the agency regarding this matter.
Thursday’s after-hours decline extends a devastating period for FICO stock. Shares collapsed nearly 49% during September trading.
One trading session was responsible for the majority of that loss. On September 29, FICO shares plunged 27% after the FHFA approved VantageScore as an acceptable credit scoring model for mortgage underwriting.
The approval allows mortgage originators to utilize VantageScore more extensively on loans they package and sell to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. The decision ended FICO’s decades-long monopoly as the sole accepted scoring system in the government-backed mortgage space.
The credit reporting landscape is controlled by three companies: Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. These three firms collectively own VantageScore, which represents FICO’s primary competitive threat.
Director Pulte has repeatedly advocated for reducing credit reporting expenses for several months. In early September, he publicly stated the FHFA was “seriously considering” implementing a two-bureau requirement.
Shifting to a bi-merge model would strike dual revenue streams simultaneously. Fair Isaac would encounter increased competition from VantageScore while the credit bureaus would experience reduced sales of tri-merge reports.
Bank of America cut its rating on FICO shares earlier this week. Analysts highlighted growing concerns about the company’s ability to maintain premium pricing in mortgage-related products.
Rocket Mortgage recently selected VantageScore as its primary scoring tool. This strategic decision intensifies fears that major mortgage lenders are shifting away from FICO’s traditional scoring products.
Fair Isaac continues to generate consistent income from its comprehensive decisioning software platforms. These subscription-driven products serve clients across numerous sectors beyond residential lending.
Analysts monitoring the company note Fair Isaac carries substantial debt obligations. This leverage could constrain the firm’s strategic options if competitive pressure in mortgage scoring continues to escalate.
FICO shares have collapsed almost 65% year-to-date. Daily trading volume averages approximately 453,000 shares.
The company’s market capitalization currently stands around $13.34 billion. Technical indicators signal a sell recommendation on the shares.
The post Fair Isaac (FICO) Extends September Slide as Two-Bureau Proposal Rattles Investors appeared first on Blockonomi.
