Bitcoin is absent from a quantum-risk warning published Thursday by global securities regulator IOSCO, even though the network may carry the largest stock of exposed keys in finance. Key take
Bitcoin is absent from a quantum-risk warning published Thursday by global securities regulator IOSCO, even though the network may carry the largest stock of exposed keys in finance.
Key takeaways
- A 63-page IOSCO report out Thursday puts quantum computing on the list of medium-to-long-term cyber risks facing financial markets.
- The report’s blockchain examples are Ethereum, Solana and Tron; bitcoin is not named.
- Jameson Lopp estimated in May that about 6.93 million BTC, 34.6% of the supply, sits in outputs with exposed public keys.
- IOSCO board chair Jean-Paul Servais said the financial sector should start preparing today.
IOSCO’s new report, 63 pages and out Thursday, calls quantum computing a “significant medium to long-term cybersecurity challenge” for financial markets and warns that moving blockchains to quantum-resistant cryptography may be especially hard. No practical quantum computer capable of breaking widely used cryptography exists today, the report states. Industry participants cited in it argue firms should prepare for such machines within five years, while the report’s conservative estimates put them in the 2030 to 2035 window.
“The scale and duration of the transition mean the financial sector should start preparing today,” IOSCO board chair Jean-Paul Servais said in the watchdog’s news release. The report sets no rules. It urges firms to migrate to post-quantum cryptography and describes a tendency it calls “quantum-procrastination,” in which firms recognise the threat but wait for clearer rules or more mature technology. It also warns of “harvest now, decrypt later” attacks, in which data collected today is unlocked later by future machines.
Replacing a blockchain’s signatures requires hard forks and coordinated action across thousands of independent validators, and decentralised networks have no way to force a fast upgrade. The report says that could make any migration “slow and fragmented.” The tradeoff is size: ML-DSA-44, a post-quantum standard published by the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology, produces signatures of about 2,420 bytes against the 64-byte ones bitcoin uses today, a 35-to-40-fold jump. A test on Solana’s quantum-resistant testnet in April saw throughput fall by about 90%.
Bitcoin is not named in the report, whose blockchain examples are Ethereum, Solana and Tron. By a May tally from bitcoin developer Jameson Lopp, exposed keys cover roughly 6.93 million BTC, a bit over a third of all coins, much of it in early pay-to-public-key outputs and reused addresses. The report notes that a capable attacker could derive private keys from public keys already visible on a network, and that dormant assets tied to exposed keys may be hard to move if their holders cannot be identified or cannot act.
Draft proposals aim at the problem. BIP 360 would add a new output type in the style of Taproot that keeps the public key off the chain, though it does not protect coins whose keys are already exposed. BIP 361, co-authored by Lopp, would phase out legacy signatures, but Lopp has said the next steps for now do not include it.
IOSCO says it will keep quantum computing a priority in 2027.